Thermoformed Parts in Practice
Standard Trays vs. Custom Tray Solutions: Which Option Is Best for Your Project?
Anyone sourcing plastic trays for transport, storage, or production quickly faces the question: choose a standard tray from the catalog or have a custom solution developed by a thermoforming specialist? Both options have their place. The right choice depends on the component, quantity, budget, and project requirements. This article explains which option is the right one for you.
Sarah Guaglianone
Updated on August 7, 2026
Contents
Standard Trays vs. Custom Tray Solutions – The Most Important Points at a Glance
- Standard trays are suitable for uncomplicated components, fast availability, and small quantities without tooling costs.
- Custom tray solutions are worthwhile for exact fits, automation, series production, and special protection requirements.
- The key factors are component geometry, process reliability, quantity, budget, and planned service life.
→ formary offers both options: standard thermoformed inserts in the online shop and custom-made trays via the configurator.
What Are Standard Trays?
Standard trays are prefabricated plastic trays with defined outer dimensions, compartment geometries, and stacking heights. They often fit common container systems such as SLC and Euro containers.
The most important advantage: the thermoforming tool already exists. This means there are no new tooling costs, and the trays are usually available at short notice. Standard trays are often used for simple transport, storage, or sorting tasks. They are especially suitable when the component is robust and does not require exact positional fixation.
What Are Custom Tray Solutions?
Custom tray solutions are tailor-made plastic trays or inserts that are precisely matched to the component, container system, and process. Cavities, cavity depth, support surfaces, gripping spaces, stacking stops, and material are planned specifically for the project.
Unlike standard trays, a new thermoforming tool is created for a custom solution. This results in one-time tooling costs. In return, the tray can be designed exactly for its intended application. Custom trays are often used when components are sensitive, require a defined position, or are to be handled automatically.
Decision Criteria at a Glance: Standard Tray or Custom Tray Solution?
The choice between standard trays and custom trays or inserts depends on several factors. The following table shows the most important differences:
| Criterion | Standard Tray | Custom Tray Solution |
|---|---|---|
| Initial costs | low, no tooling costs | higher, as a tool must be created |
| Delivery time | usually 2–5 days | project-dependent, usually 3–6 weeks |
| Precision fit | limited by existing compartment geometries | exactly matched to the component |
| Component protection | sufficient for robust parts | high for sensitive or complex parts |
| Process reliability | good for simple processes | high for defined series processes |
| Automation | only possible if the geometry happens to fit | can be planned specifically |
| Material selection | limited | can be selected project-specifically |
| Stackability | predefined | can be planned individually |
| Unit costs | usually relatively constant | often decrease as quantity increases |
| Flexibility | low | high during the development phase |
When Is a Standard Tray Sufficient?
A standard tray is sufficient when your component is robust, fits into existing compartments, and does not require exact positional fixation. In this case, fast availability and low initial costs matter more than maximum precision fit.
Typical use cases include:
- Internal sorting
- Storage
- Order picking
- Simple transport tasks
- Pre-series or short-term projects
- Components without sensitive surfaces
- Applications without automation
Standard trays are particularly attractive when only small quantities are needed or when a quick interim solution is required. Since no new tool has to be built, procurement can begin much faster.
Standard Trays as an Inventory Aid
Standard trays are not only suitable for transport and storage, but also as practical support for inventory counting. Fixed compartments, defined quantities per tray, and a clear visual structure make it easier to count, inspect, and assign components.
Especially for small parts, serial parts, or recurring components, standard trays can help organize stock more clearly. Employees can see at a glance whether a compartment is occupied, whether parts are missing, or whether a defined quantity is complete.
Typical advantages during inventory counting include:
- Faster counting thanks to a fixed number of compartments
- Better overview of small parts
- Easy separation of different components
- Less searching effort in storage
- Clear assignment to SLC, Eurobox, or storage location
- Better preparation for picking and reordering
If components fit into an existing standard compartment, standard trays can be a simple and cost-efficient inventory aid—without new tooling costs and with fast availability.
When Is a Custom Tray Solution Worthwhile?
A custom tray solution is worthwhile when the tray must do more than just “fit” and instead secure a defined process. This is especially relevant when components are sensitive, must not shift, or must always be positioned the same way in automated workflows.
Custom trays enable:
- Precisely fitting cavities
- Defined component orientation
- Targeted support points
- Gripping spaces for robots or handling systems
- Controlled stacking heights
- ESD protection or cleanroom suitability
- Material selection according to the application
- Markings, colors, or special functions
Particularly in series production, a custom solution can be more economical in the long term. Tooling costs are incurred only once, while unit costs decrease as quantities rise. In addition, a precisely fitting solution reduces risks such as damage, incorrect gripping, or inefficient handling.
Why Do I Need a Custom Tool for a Tray or Insert?
A custom tool is necessary when a standard tray or standard insert does not hold your component securely enough. Standard parts have fixed outer dimensions, fixed compartment geometries, and predefined stacking heights. If the component does not fit these exactly, there will be play in the cavity.
This may be uncritical in simple applications. However, with sensitive components, painted surfaces, electronic components, medical parts, or automated processes, it can cause problems.
Possible consequences include:
- Components shifting inside the tray
- Surfaces getting scratched
- Parts not lying in a clearly defined orientation
- Robots or grippers picking incorrectly
- Stacks not being guided safely
- Transport and storage becoming less process-reliable
With a custom thermoforming tool, cavities, support surfaces, cavity depth, wall angles, gripping spaces, and stacking stops are specifically adapted to your component. This results in one-time tooling costs, but gives you a solution that exactly matches the component, process, and quantity.
Costs: Standard Tray vs. Custom Tray Solution
Total costs consist of tooling costs, unit costs, material, complexity, and project duration. Standard trays involve no new tooling costs. However, shape, compartment geometry, and material selection are predefined. Custom tray solutions involve one-time tooling costs, but can offer lower unit costs and higher process reliability for medium to large quantities.
Note: The following figures are general rules of thumb. Depending on complexity, size, quantity, etc., there may be deviations.
Example Costs for a Standard Tray:
- Tooling costs: €0
- Unit price: €5–15 (depending on size and material)
- Available from stock
Example Costs for a Custom Tray Solution:
- Tooling costs: €2,000–8,000 (depending on complexity)
- Unit price in series production: €3–10 (decreases as quantity increases)
- Project lead time: 3–6 weeks
Availability and Delivery Time
Standard trays are usually available from stock and can be delivered within a few days. This makes them ideal for urgent projects, pre-series runs, or fast procurement without long lead times.
Custom tray solutions require more development time. This includes:
- Technical review
- Design
- Toolmaking
- Sampling
- Series approval
Project lead time is usually 3–6 weeks, depending on the complexity of the tray.
Comparison of Availability for Standard and Custom Solutions
| Tray Type | Delivery Time | Advance Planning Required? |
|---|---|---|
| Standard tray | 2–5 days | no |
| Custom solution | 3–6 weeks | yes (design, toolmaking) |
Precision Fit and Process Reliability of Custom Trays and Standard Parts
Precision fit is one of the most important differences between standard trays and custom tray solutions. With standard trays, the component has to fit into an existing compartment geometry. This may be sufficient if the component is robust and some movement in the compartment is not a problem. However, with sensitive parts, this play can lead to scratches, pressure marks, or unstable positioning.
Custom tray solutions, by contrast, are developed directly around the component. This makes it possible to design cavities, support points, and cavity depths so that the component lies securely and is protected.
Precision fit in comparison
- Standard tray: Component fits “approximately,” with some play
- Custom solution: Component sits in a form-fitting cavity, with a defined position
If your process is automated or requires high repeat accuracy, the custom solution is almost always the better choice. For manual sorting or simple storage processes, the standard solution is often sufficient.
Material Selection and Special Requirements
Standard trays are usually offered in common materials and colors. Depending on the product range, ESD variants may also be available. However, the selection remains limited to existing versions.
Custom tray solutions offer full material flexibility. You can choose between all common thermoplastics: PP, PS, ABS, PC, PET-A, PET-G, PMMA, or compounds. This also makes ESD protection, cleanroom suitability, special wall thicknesses, or surface treatments possible.
Comparison of Material Selection for Standard Trays and Custom Tray Solutions
| Tray Type | Material Selection | ESD, Cleanroom? |
|---|---|---|
| Standard tray | limited (PP, PS, PET-G) | partially available |
| Custom solution | fully configurable | yes, can be planned |
Automation and Robot Handling
For manual processes, a standard tray is often sufficient. As soon as trays are used in automated systems, the requirements increase significantly. Robots and grippers need defined component positions, reproducible distances, and sufficient gripping space. With a standard tray, this is only possible if the existing geometry happens to match the component and the gripping system.
Custom tray solutions, on the other hand, can be designed for automation from the very beginning. This includes:
- Defined component orientation
- Gripping spaces for robots
- Consistent cavity positions
- Stacking stops
- Alignment aids
- Poka-yoke features
- Stable tray geometry for repeatable processes
In short: If automation is planned, a custom solution is in many cases the better choice.
Small Series or Large Series: Which Solution Fits the Quantity?
For small quantities under 100 units, standard trays are usually more economical. The lack of tooling costs has a direct impact on total costs. Standard solutions also often remain the first choice for pre-series runs, prototypes, or short-term projects.
From medium series onward (200–500 units), a custom solution often becomes worthwhile. The tooling costs are spread across more parts, and unit costs decrease. For large series (>1,000 units), the custom solution is almost always cheaper and offers better process reliability.
Quantity Comparison of Standard Trays and Custom Trays
| Quantity | Recommendation |
|---|---|
| < 100 units | Standard tray usually cheaper |
| 100–500 units | Comparison worthwhile |
| > 500 units | Custom solution usually cheaper |
These values are guidelines. What matters is not only the quantity, but also the risk: if a damaged component is expensive or process errors cause high follow-up costs, a custom solution can also be worthwhile for smaller quantities.
Stackability and Storage Efficiency
Standard trays are often stackable, but stacking heights are predefined. If your storage system has special requirements, this can be problematic.
With custom tray solutions, stackability can be developed specifically. This is particularly relevant when many trays are in circulation or when containers, shelves, and transport carts need to be used optimally.
The following can be planned, for example:
- Defined stacking heights
- Secure stacking stops
- Nestable/reversible stacking
- Space-saving empty trays
- Stack security
- Adaptation to SLC, Eurobox, or special containers
If storage space is expensive or many trays are in permanent use, optimized stackability can significantly improve cost-effectiveness.
Decision Guide: Which Tray Solution Fits Your Project?
The following checklist helps with the selection:
A standard tray is probably sufficient if:
- The component is robust
- The component fits into an existing compartment
- No exact positional fixation is required
- The quantity is small
- The solution must be available quickly
- Tooling costs should be avoided
- No automation is planned
A custom tray solution is probably advisable if:
- The component is sensitive or complex
- Surfaces must be protected
- A defined component orientation is required
- Automation or robot handling is planned
- ESD protection, cleanroom suitability, or special materials are required
- Stackability should be specifically designed
- Medium to large series are planned
Hybrid Approach: Standard Tray as an Interim Solution
In some projects, time is short, but a custom solution makes more sense in the long term. In that case, a standard tray can serve as an interim solution.
How the Hybrid Approach Works:
- Order the standard tray immediately (production can start)
- Develop the custom solution in parallel (design, toolmaking)
- Switch to the custom solution after 3–6 weeks
This ensures operational readiness while enabling long-term optimization at the same time. This approach is especially useful during production ramp-ups or urgent projects.
What Data Is Needed for an Inquiry?
The better the data available, the faster a suitable solution can be evaluated.
For standard trays, the following is usually required:
- Container dimensions, e.g. SLC or Eurobox
- Desired number of compartments or compartment size
- Quantity
- Material or ESD requirement, if relevant
For custom tray solutions, the following is usually required:
- Component geometry, e.g. CAD data, drawing, or photo
- Outer dimensions of the tray or container system
- Number of compartments or desired packing density
- Material requirements
- Planned quantity
- Intended use: transport, storage, assembly, or automation
- Special requirements such as stackability, gripping spaces, color, labeling, or ESD protection
The more complete your information, the faster you will receive a suitable quotation. Our configurator guides you step by step through the inquiry process.
formary also supports you when data is missing through technical consultation, and if CAD data for your tray already exists, it can be analyzed for thermoformability using the automated DfM analysis.
Conclusion: Standard Tray or Custom Tray Solution?
Standard trays and custom tray solutions are not competing options, but answers to different requirements. Standard trays stand out for fast availability and low initial costs. Custom solutions offer precision fit, process reliability, and long-term cost-effectiveness.
The deciding factors are component geometry, quantity, process requirements, and budget. If you are unsure which solution fits, have your project reviewed technically. formary offers both paths: standard thermoformed inserts in the online shop and custom-made trays via the configurator or the 3D tray generator.
FAQ – Standard Trays vs. Custom Tray Solutions
Why do I need a custom tool for a tray or insert instead of a standard part?
A custom tool is necessary when a standard tray or standard insert does not hold your component securely enough. Standard parts have fixed outer dimensions, compartment geometries, and stacking heights. If your component is sensitive, complex in shape, or intended for a defined process, too much play in the compartment can lead to shifting, scratches, misgrips, or unstable stacking.
With a custom thermoforming tool, cavities, cavity depth, support surfaces, gripping spaces, stacking stops, and material are specifically adapted to your component and your process. This involves one-time tooling costs, but gives you a precisely fitting tray or insert with higher process reliability, better component protection, and often lower unit costs in series production.
Further Content
Thermoformed Parts in Practice
What Is a Workpiece Carrier? Definition & Applications
A constant challenge in the manufacturing industry is efficiently managing material flow throughout all assembly stages and departments. These logistical challenges can be optimally addressed by using product-specific workpiece carriers. Learn more in this article.
Thermoformed Parts in Practice
Design for Manufacturing (DfM): Guide to Manufacturing-Oriented Design
With the new Design for Manufacturing analysis from formary, it is now possible to check CAD data for thermoformability in a matter of seconds, allowing potential sources of error to be identified early on before they become costly. Read on to find out what features the DfM software offers and what the Design for Manufacturing principle entails.
Thermoformed Parts in Practice
Design Guidelines for Plastic Thermoformed Parts – Top 13 Tips for Plastic-Optimized Construction
Plastic thermoforming is shaped by factors like material quality, temperature, pressure, speed, and tool geometry. With the right design principles, you can prevent errors in CAD and production. formary has gathered key tips to help you optimize your thermoformed parts.
Thermoformed Parts in Practice
Construction Data in Thermoforming: These Factors Must Be Considered for Plastic Deep Drawn Parts
Deep drawn parts are custom-made and designed individually in a CAD format. Before a deep drawing tool is manufactured, a customer approval process of the CAD data or the derived, dimensioned PDF drawing takes place.
Thermoformed Parts in Practice
Checking CAD Models for Thermoformability: The Designer's Guide
Whether a plastic part is thermoformable is determined in the CAD model. Anyone who discusses geometry, wall thicknesses, and demoldability only after the first sampling pays for this loop with tool modifications, material waste, and lost weeks in the project timeline. This can be avoided during design: with a structured check that evaluates each model along this guide and makes typical sources of error visible early on.
Platform & Features
Ordering Standard Plastic Thermoformed Inserts: Step by Step for the formary Online Shop
Standard plastic thermoformed inserts are suitable for companies that want to equip SLCs or Euro containers quickly, without tooling costs and starting from small quantities. The formary Online Shop offers 220 ready-made inserts, including standard versions made from white PS and ESD-resistant versions made from conductive black PS. In this article, we show you step by step how to find suitable standard thermoformed inserts in the formary Online Shop, check technical details, request a sample and then obtain a quotation.
Thermoformed Parts in Practice
Starting Thickness vs. Wall Thickness in Thermoforming: Why Material Thickness Does Not Equal Wall Thickness
During plastic thermoforming, a plastic sheet or film is heated, stretched and drawn over or into a mold. This changes the material’s original starting thickness: the wall thickness of the finished thermoformed part is not uniform throughout. Anyone designing or sourcing thermoformed plastic parts must understand this relationship in order to dimension parts correctly, avoid thin spots and calculate costs realistically.
Thermoformed Parts in Practice
Standard Trays vs. Custom Tray Solutions: Which Option Is Best for Your Project?
Anyone sourcing plastic trays for transport, storage, or production quickly faces the question: choose a standard tray from the catalog or have a custom solution developed by a thermoforming specialist? Both options have their place. The right choice depends on the component, quantity, budget, and project requirements. This article explains which option is the right one for you.